INDEPENDENT. FAN-RUN. COMMUNITY-DRIVEN.NEXT UP Kilmarnock v Aberdeen · Sat 21 Nov, 15:00
Aberdeen FC Fan Zone — By fans. For fans.Follow us on Facebook
← All storiesFAN OPINION

Next Aberdeen manager: our attacking football shortlist

Who should be the next Aberdeen manager? Aberdeen FC Fan Zone makes the case for Pascal Jansen, Karel Geraerts and Henrik Rydström. See the reported odds and vote for your pick.

Fan Zone illustration of a red dugout under floodlights
Artwork by Aberdeen FC Fan Zone

Aberdeen appointed Mario Frick on 15 November. Read our guide to Aberdeen’s new manager.

Manager search update — 13 November

Aberdeen are still looking for Stephen Robinson’s successor. In Monday’s departure statement, the club said Stuart Duff would take interim charge of first-team training while the search continued. As of Friday’s check, there’s no appointment on the club’s news page.

The Daily Record reported that Aberdeen had spoken to seven candidates. The Press and Journal says chief executive Adrian Bevington and sporting director Lutz Pfannenstiel are leading the search, with the club aiming to have a new boss in place for the trip to Kilmarnock on Saturday 21 November. The club has yet to give a date.

Steve Clarke is among the names the Press and Journal says Aberdeen have considered. It also reported that former Motherwell boss Michael Wimmer had expressed interest. In our separate Raphaël Wicky feature, we looked at how his sides played at Young Boys, Basel and Sporting Kansas City.

If it was your call, what would matter most in the next appointment? Cast your vote below.

We want teams to come to Pittodrie knowing they’re in for a horrible afternoon. We want their centre-backs rushing passes, their full-backs pinned deep and their manager wondering how he’s going to get his team out of their own half.

When was the last time we walked through the turnstiles expecting that?

Aberdeen sacked Stephen Robinson on 9 November, two days after the 4–0 home defeat to Hibs. The Dons were 11th with three wins from 12 league games. Stuart Duff has taken interim charge of first-team training while the club searches for a head coach.

We’ve deliberately looked further afield for our shortlist. That’s why we’ve left out the usual names that come up when a Scottish job opens. You’ll still see some of them in the reported odds below. We wanted to see what coaches working in other leagues could bring to Pittodrie.

We want fearless attacking football, aggressive pressing, a team that still goes looking for a second goal at 1–0, and standards that run from the academy to the first team. Here’s who we’d call, based on coaching roles checked on 10 November 2026.

1. Pascal Jansen | Our first call

Jansen took AZ Alkmaar to the Europa Conference League semi-finals in 2023. We liked how much freedom young players had within a clear team shape. Give the winger licence to come inside, give him someone to combine with and make sure somebody covers if the move breaks down. We can see that working at Pittodrie.

New York City FC have announced his departure. He took them to the Eastern Conference final in 2025, then missed the play-offs in 2026. We’d ask him what stopped working in year two and what he could change at Pittodrie in his first fortnight. Aberdeen need points while the next coach gets his ideas across. Interest in the job and what it would cost are questions for that first call.

2. Karel Geraerts | A more aggressive Aberdeen

Geraerts’s Union Saint-Gilloise pushed for the Belgian title in 2023. His football is the most direct on our list. Win the ball, get forward quickly and give the man in possession somebody to hit. We can see Pittodrie getting behind that.

Schalke and Reims temper the excitement. Reims confirmed his departure in May. Belgian coverage subsequently reported he was without a club, and we couldn’t verify a newer appointment. We’d ask what happens when a visiting side sits deep and takes away the space to counter. Aberdeen need to create chances on those afternoons too.

Henrik Rydström | The ambitious enquiry

Rydström is the coach whose football excites us most. He won back-to-back Swedish titles with Malmö using ideas drawn from Brazilian coach Fernando Diniz. Players moved towards the ball, swapped positions and played quick combinations in tight spaces. A winger could come inside to help beat the press and pop up somewhere entirely different before the move was over. That’s the sort of football we’d buy a ticket to watch.

Columbus dismissed him after three wins in 14 MLS games. He’s now Hammarby’s head coach. We’d find out what it would take to speak to him and keep the search moving while we waited. If he did come in for an interview, we’d want to hear which parts of his game he could teach this squad by Christmas.

Three coaches who help define the brief

Albert Riera is head coach at Red Star Belgrade. His league and cup double with Olimpija Ljubljana and his attacking work at Celje explain the appeal. His short spell at Eintracht Frankfurt raises a question about how quickly his ideas translate when results are urgent. With a job in Belgrade, he’d be well down our list of calls.

Pepijn Lijnders is an assistant to Jürgen Klopp with Germany. His work with Klopp at Liverpool and Pep Guardiola at Manchester City makes him interesting if you want Aberdeen to win the ball back the instant we lose it. Salzburg ended his spell as head coach within months, though. We’d put more weight on what Jansen and Geraerts have shown running their own teams.

Eirik Horneland is back at Brann on a deal through 2030. Aberdeen held talks with him earlier this year, and we can see why. His Brann side pressed hard and kept looking for chances when they were ahead. We’d use what he built there as a benchmark for this search.

What Pfannenstiel and Bevington bring to the search

Sporting director Lutz Pfannenstiel spent nine years in international relations and scouting at Hoffenheim and helped build St Louis City’s football operation in MLS. That experience could give Aberdeen a way into conversations in Germany and North America, and a chance to get references on coaches whose work we rarely see here.

Chief executive Adrian Bevington spent 17 years at the English FA and has worked with Middlesbrough, Nottingham Forest, Aston Villa and the Welsh FA. At his first Aberdeen press conference, he said his network could complement the football staff’s. We’d use those contacts to ask how a coach works day to day and whether the job at Pittodrie would appeal to them.

The club says preparatory work was already under way when Robinson left. We’d like to see both networks used to widen the search, then judge every candidate on what they could do with this squad. Aberdeen have given no details of who has been contacted.

What we’d ask in the interview

You’ve got this squad, a home game on Saturday and an opposition side happy to sit in. What will we see Aberdeen do differently?

We want to hear who gets closer to the striker, when the team presses and who covers when the full-back goes. Then we want the board to explain how recruitment and the academy will support that way of playing. If the plan is to press high, we need players who can repeat those efforts and youngsters who already know when to go. Otherwise, the next coach inherits another squad built for somebody else’s football.

We’d call Jansen first, speak to Geraerts and find out whether an approach for Rydström has any legs. Jansen is our pick because we can see him giving Aberdeen a recognisable style while getting to grips with a relegation fight.

The board can ask whether the next manager knows Scottish football. We’d rather hear how he plans to make Scottish football worry about coming to Pittodrie again.

Sources and coaching status checks

Read our report on Robinson’s departure ↗

Have your saySee Fan Zone Weekly ↗

Have your say

Who should be the next Aberdeen manager?

Loading votes…

THE SUPPORTERS’ VIEW

What’s your take?

Agree with the report? See it differently? Add your own thoughts.

Football criticism is welcome. No swearing, abuse, discrimination, adverts or personal information. Nicknames are public and are not verified identities. Every comment is checked automatically before it appears. Checks can make mistakes; use Report if something slips through.

0/1,000 characters

Supporter comments

Loading comments…

Keep the conversation going

THE CONVERSATION STARTS WITH YOU

Around 6,000 Dons. Room for one more.

Follow us on Facebook